Elmwood Agency

tom clark

2 months ago

Tiffany is a fantastic insurance agent. This is the 3rd agency I’ve followed her to because I trust her knowledge and to always get me the best coverage and rates.

Jenna Hagen

2 months ago

Rick Gangale was extremely helpful, patient and quick to find coverage! I am grateful to him for his hard work and kindness. Would recommend to any family or friends shopping around.

Ermias Gebremariam

5 months ago

Was shopping for Home insurance as a new home buyer. I was recommended Elmwood by my two of my co-workers. Gave them a call and Worked with Karen and she was awesome. Her quote compared to others companies I contacted was significantly better and included everything I was looking for. And she was also able to save me close to $500 a year on my car insurance. Nothing was salesy at all either. Highly recommend Elmwood.

jellyrcw12

6 months ago

A coworker recommended Elmwood Agency to me. Richard Gangale did a fantastic job providing me with home owner's insurance and auto insurance quotes that were at better rates and higher quality than my previous broker. The process was easy to follow and he communicated clearly and frequently. I'm definitely happy I changed my insurance.

Shelby Bedzyk

2 months ago

I worked with Rick Gangale to get a home and auto insurance combo quote. He was prompt, communicative, courteous, and helpful throughout the process. I would have no qualms about recommending his/Elmwood's services to family or friends. Thanks y'all!

Deborah Armstrong

4 months ago

Courtney with Elwood Agency provided exceptional service and gave me the best, most affordable options for Automobile Insurance. She was professional, friendly, and efficient. Called her in the afternoon and by the next morning, she was calling with recommendations. Just wonderful!

Kelly Roland

3 months ago

I did a lot of research before switching insurance agencies found the Elmwood Agency based both on recommendations and online reviews. Working with Karen Seiler was amazing! She is so incredibly knowledgeable about the insurance industry, gave me sound advice, options, and carriers to consider, and listened when I explained my insurance needs. (Not to mention that I saved a considerable amount of money in the process.) I can't recommend her or the agency highly enough!

Dakota Turner

a month ago

I worked directly with Karen and she was so nice! She took the reigns for me and found and amazing insurance policy and even though we had sad circumstances and lost the house she helped us cancel the policy and was sympathetic! I will always recommend this agency! I will be back when I get the next house! Thank yku Elmwood and Karen!

Eli VanOrman

2 months ago

Nick at Elmwood Agency has been an absolutely phenomenal resource to me and my insurance policies. When I was introduced to Nick all of my policies were spread out and it resulted in some gaps in my exposure. Since working with Nick I now have more then enough coverage and I am in a much more secure position. Nick and his team are extremely professional, responsive and proactive with my needs. Highly recommend!

helen halewski

a month ago

I recently moved my home, auto, and umbrella coverage to Elmwood Agency, and the experience has been excellent. I worked directly with Matthew Fantauzzo, and he has been exceptionally responsive and professional throughout the process. I came into the transition having done significant research and with a clear sense of the coverage structures I wanted to explore. Matthew worked through multiple iterations with me — adjusting liability limits, reviewing umbrella options, and running various scenarios — and handled each change quickly and clearly. What stood out most was his responsiveness and willingness to engage thoughtfully in a detailed process. He treated the decisions seriously and ensured everything was implemented accurately. The transition was smooth, and I appreciate the professionalism. I would recommend Elmwood Agency to anyone looking for a responsive and organized insurance team.